Return to Front Page shop.GIF (2398 bytes)
Interview I Builder Profile Shop Safety Sailing Stuff BYYB News
BYYB Profile Launchings Regattas Sailing Stories Builders Tales
Book Review        
   fhagan.JPG (6308 bytes)

 

 

By Frank Hagan

 

Shop Tips:

Ventilation and Filtration

 


     The Gaff Rig recognizes that boat building involves inherently dangerous activities, and each builder must be responsible for his own safety. The Gaff Rig encourages all builders to read manufacturer’s instructions, follow all safety precautions, and be pro-active in seeking out more information on reducing the risk of injury or illness. Information presented here is general in nature and not intended to replace the safety instructions provided with products or tools.


 

     We tend to think the most dangerous things in our boat building shops as those whirring blades of metal that would rip us apart just as easily as they tear through wood. Yet we know more insidious dangers lie in the more mundane things such as chemical exposure, lung and eye irritants, etc.
     Most of us use "typical" safety measures such as latex gloves to prevent accidental contact with chemicals, and dust masks to prevent breathing in sawdust. That dust mask is fine for some tasks, but the truth may be that wood dust, from sanding and sawing, may be the most hazardous thing we are exposed to because we don’t give it the respect it deserves. Exposure to chemical vapors pose another hazard, because they go straight through that dust mask without hesitation.
     How much exposure is safe? OHSA, the US Occupational Health and Safety Administration, publishes two kinds of "allowable exposure" ratings. One rating is for continuous exposure over an eight hour period, which I’ll call the workplace rating. The other is a "short term" exposure rating. For wood dust, OHSA set the workplace exposure limit at 5 milligrams per square meter, and for short term exposure, 10 milligrams per square meter. How much wood dust is that? For a 20 x 20 foot shop with a 10 foot ceiling, a single teaspoon of wood dust would exceed 10 milligrams per square meter.
     Before you give up sanding forever, as tempting as that is, realize that teaspoon would have to be evenly distributed in the air in the shop, and that rarely happens. Larger wood particles fall to the floor immediately, and even smaller ones tend to fall out after a brief period. Our intermittent use of tools, which are off when we are in the "moaning chair" with our favorite adult beverage, helps us (remember that next time your significant other asks why you are sitting there staring at the boat.) Still, our proximity to the tool means we are probably exposed to far greater concentrations than a simple teaspoon for short periods of time. Its something to think about next time you’re tempted to lean in close to the belt sander to see through the cloud of dust.dust.JPG (12790 bytes)
     Many of us have seen the professional dust collection systems to capture sawdust at its source in large shops. But buying that kind of equipment for our home shops, especially if the shop is new and geared to building just this single boat, is out of reach for most of us. Still, there are easy solutions to the problem that don’t cost a fortune.
     Home systems, that hook up to a single machine, can be purchased for less than $200. Dust collection systems are rated according to cubic feet per minute (cfm) of air they move. If you are considering purchasing a system, keep in mind that most home shop tools need at least a 350 cfm unit (that’s good for a 10" table saw, 14" band saw, 6" jointer, 12" disc sander, 16" drill press and an oscillating spindle sander.) Radial arm saws vary, from 350 to 500 cfm, depending on brand. And larger woodworking machines need more dust collection power. The manufacturers of the tools will be able to provide a recommendation for their specific tool. The dust bags used on these systems don’t trap the finest, and most dangerous particles, so most manufacturers still recommend you utilize a shop filter and/or a good cartridge respirator.
     There’s an even better solution than a dust collector, shop filter and cartridge respirator: ventilation. fan.JPG (10875 bytes)       In nice weather, opening all the doors and windows can go a long way to reduce our exposure. Still, clouds of wood dust can billow up right around us if the air is relatively still. The common box-style fan which most of us already own can help us with "assisted ventilation." I prefer to place the fan behind me in a door or window opening, blowing the dust away from me as I work, and providing me with a stream of fresh air. In enclosed areas, such as the cabin of our boats, I prefer to have the box fan blowing air out of the front hatch, bringing fresh air into the cabin (and I try to remember to work with the sander between me and the fan.)
     During cold weather, having the doors open and a fan blowing might not be possible. Although not quite as effective as dust collection systems and filters, shop filtration systems by themselves can cut down on airborne wood dust at a fairly economical cost.
     fanfilt.JPG (9575 bytes)The commercial units still take up valuable boat-building dollars. An alternative is our common box fan again, with a furnace filter in front of it. This low-tech solution can be made pretty efficient with the new allergy filters that trap smaller particulate matter. Some shops build elaborate boxes to house the fan and hold the filter, but the fan can easily hold the filter in place once it is turned on. Simple, low cost, and it works.
     Filtration works with most wood dust, but isn’t much help with chemical exposure. And even with wood dust, without plenty of ventilation, you could still have that teaspoon of fine wood dust floating in the air. A good cartridge respirator is needed.
     Nearly every home improvement chain store sells cartridge respirators at an economical price in the paint department. They are adequate for most chemicals we come in contact with. I use a respirator with a "hepa" style filter adequate for working with refractory materials (it filters out very small particles.) But, because of my beard, it doesn’t seal well against my face, and I make sure there’s plenty of ventilation as well. That means I simply can’t do some tasks when its really cold outside, or I have to brave the cold.
     In the hierarchy of methods to control exposure, most experts put ventilation as the best approach, combined with or followed by use of a good cartridge respirator. The most expensive solutions, filtration and dust collection actually fall in third place, and usually still require the use of a respirator.  

 

     Top of Page